Neutral vs. Stability Shoes: The Ultimate Guide

Before we dive into the differences between neutral and stability shoes, let’s talk briefly about over and underpronating. When you step down, your ankle should roll slightly to transfer pressure from your heels to the balls of your feet. If this motion goes too far and your feet roll inward when you walk, that’s called overpronating. If you don’t roll far enough to move that pressure and your foot rolls outward when you walk, that’s called underpronation or supination. 

So, what is a stability shoe? Stability shoes are specially designed for people, often runners, who overpronate. The design of stability shoes is meant to guide overpronators back to a healthier gait. Neutral shoes, however, are just what the name implies: shoes for people with a neutral gait. Because these shoes don’t need extra cushion or technology to counter pronation, they tend to be lighter and often have more cushion in the heel.

Neutral vs. Stability Shoes Comparison Chart

Beyond the general guideline that stability shoes are for overpronators and neutral shoes are for those with a neutral gait or underpronate, several distinct features set the styles apart. In both cases, the design differences are meant to maintain a neutral gait. Stability shoes generally offer firmer support and include a medial post to correct for overpronation. Neutral shoes, on the other hand, focus on maintaining your natural foot motion and cushioning impact. Check out the table below for a detailed side-by-side comparison of features.

But What About Motion Control Shoes?

If you’ve been researching questions like “what is a good stability running shoe?” or “What is a stability shoe for running?” you may have run into motion control shoes. Motion control shoes are designed for people with severe overpronation, which often means folks with extremely fallen arches or flat feet. 

While neutral shoes aim to maintain the motion the wearer is already making as they walk, motion control shoes are all about steering someone who is walking differently toward that same motion. The extra tech and support this requires often make motion control shoes heavier and less flexible than neutral shoes. 

In some ways, motion control shoes are a more extreme version of stability shoes. While they have much in common, motion control shoes will be heavier and more rigid than stability shoes. This is because of aggressive arch support to lift those fallen arches and extremely firm heel support to counteract the foot’s tendency to overpronate.

Foot Motion

Whether you need stability shoes or neutral shoes is directly tied to your natural foot motion. If you are pronating the correct amount, stability shoes will help you maintain that neutral foot motion with each step while offering extra cushioning at the heel to protect it from the repeated impacts it takes while walking. These shoes tend to be more flexible, allowing your regular gait to come through with less resistance.

However, if you are overpronating, your foot will likely roll too far inward with each step. This can cause extra strain and stress on the muscles and ligaments in your feet, a problem that may extend up through your legs and into joints like your knees and hips. Stability shoes will often feature medial posting (extra support at your midfoot) to push back against this inward motion and direct the landing point toward the ball of your feet like nature intended. 

Foot motion is important because when you deviate from a standard gait, you put extra pressure and strain on your body. When these areas get hurt, your body shifts your balance and stride to protect those areas from more pain. These changes, in turn, put stress and strain on new muscles, ligaments and joints—meaning foot pain can radiate to other parts of your body if left untreated.

The Midsole

Insoles, some of which are removable, are part of the shoe your foot lays flat on inside the shoe. The outsole is the part of your shoe that makes contact with the ground. The midsole is the part in between the two, and that’s often where a shoe has most of its cushioning. 

Neutral shoes don’t need to correct your gait, so those midsoles tend to be focused primarily on providing a soft cushion to reduce pressure and impact as you step down. The midsole in a stability shoe will also feature some cushion, but the primary goal is pushing back against overpronation. This requires more rigid structure and firmer support than you’d find in a neutral shoe’s midsole, often in the form of medial posting.

Support Features

What is the difference between a neutral running shoe and a stability running shoe? The key difference is the extra support features seen in stability shoes, so let’s talk about some of those. 

One of the main support features you will come across in stability shoes is a medial post, or “posting” in general. Posting refers to adding stability to a part of the shoe to counteract the excessive rolling motion of overpronating. This can take the form of plates, rods, or dual-density foam, with the more dense foams forming the support post. These posts are often added to the medial part of the shoe and sometimes around the heel. A heel bevel, a rounded heel, can also help promote a more natural gait. 

Other support features in stability shoes may include side walls, which bring support up from the midsole along the sides of your feet, or a flared sole, which is a wider sole at the midfoot for extra stability.

Heel Counter

A heel counter is usually made of plastic and sits at the heel of the shoe to give it firm structure. Some shoes don’t have a heel counter, or they have one that is extremely flexible, while others are rigid to prevent the heel of the shoe from losing shape. 

Some people find rigid heel counters uncomfortable or are prone to blisters and calluses where their skin makes contact with the hard plastic, so neutral shoes tend to have much more flexibility in the heel area. 

Stability shoes, on the other foot, trade the comfort of that flexibility for rigid support that helps reduce overpronation. While a firm heel counter may take some getting used to, especially if you’ve never worn stability shoes before, your shoes should not be painful. Avoid heel counters that cause irritation or injury.

Fit

Finding your ideal fit can make a huge difference when it comes to running. The key difference between the fit of neutral and stability shoes is flexibility. A neutral shoe will have more flexibility overall, especially in the heel counter, and will generally be lighter weight. 

Stability shoes may feel different because of the extra weight, and they tend to have a more restrictive fit because they are designed to correct your gait when you walk. This can mean less flexibility and more support around your ankle and midfoot. This may also mean more rigid materials in the shoe’s overall construction, so the footwear bends less as you walk or run.

Injury Prevention

Will stability shoes prevent me from getting injured? That’s a difficult question to answer, and it depends on many factors, including your gait. Overpronation increases your risk for sprains and strains, as well as many common overuse injuries like plantar fasciitis, IT band syndrome, Achilles tendonitis, shin splints and more. 

Wearing stability shoes can help overpronators walk with a more natural gait, and walking with a more natural gait puts less stress and strain on your body for less risk of injury.

Flexibility

Regarding flexibility, you’ll find more in a neutral shoe. If you have a neutral gait, your body is already doing what you want it to do, so your shoes can feature softer or more forgiving materials that move with you. Stability shoes, as their very name implies, are more concerned with stabilizing your motion to guide you toward a neutral gait. This means they tend to be more stiff than neutral shoes. 

Comfort

When it comes to comfort and comparing neutral shoes with stability shoes, we’ve got to think about long-term and short-term comfort. Imagine how comfortable your favorite pair of house slippers are. Then, imagine how your feet would feel after wearing soft slippers through a long shift at work. At a certain point, that softness becomes a problem and your body craves support. 

Neutral shoes tend to be lighter and more flexible, which generally means they are more comfortable when you put them on, just like those soft slippers. And if you underpronate slightly or have a neutral gait, neutral shoes will probably continue to be your most comfortable option. 

However, if you overpronate, that leads to more stress, pain and fatigue over time. Stability shoes feature more control and support to correct for overpronation, and that may mean slightly less comfort in the short term. However, over the long term, the benefits from correcting your gait mean that support leads to more comfort and less pain.

Can Shoe Insoles Help with Stability?

Human bodies are unique, and we all have differently shaped feet. Depending on your foot shape and other factors, your doctor may suggest insoles or inserts for greater stability. 

How does a custom orthotic help with stability? Suppose you have uneven limbs or differences in shape from foot to foot. Your doctor may suggest a custom orthotic to correct those inconsistencies and get you walking more naturally. 

Can you use inserts inside stability shoes? The answer is yes, but that depends on the shoe and the insert. Some shoes have removable insoles that make it easier to make room in the shoe for an insert. Some low-profile shoes, or shoes without removable insoles, can be trickier with inserts—as the extra material within the shoe causes your foot to sit too high within your footwear. This mismatch can create discomfort and reduce stability. 

Neutral vs. Stability Shoes: Which Shoe is Best for You?

When choosing whether you need a neutral or stability shoe, the key thing to consider is your gait. If you have a natural gait or underpronate slightly, a neutral shoe will likely be more comfortable for you. If you overpronate, a stability shoe may feel stiff or awkward initially. Still, the long-term benefits will lead to more comfort, less pain and a reduced risk of common overuse injuries. 

How do you know how much stability you need? Well, that depends on factors like the surface you plan to run on, the shape of your feet, and whether or not you have previous injuries. 

One thing to consider is arch type. If you have fallen arches or flat feet, you are more likely to overpronate and may benefit from a stability shoe. The medial post and other supportive features help compensate for the lack of definition in your arch, guiding your foot toward a more neutral gait. 

Will you be running on paved roads, or across sand and rocky trails? Advanced traction, durable materials, and high-top ankle support all tend to be more important for trail runners, while running on pavement has fewer special needs. 

If you aren’t sure whether you overpronate, underpronate or have a neutral gait, you can visit a running store or health care specialist for a gait test. You can also observe your feet as you stand on the floor: if you have flat or low arches, most or all of your feet will be flush with the floor, while less of your foot will contact the ground if you have higher arches. 

You can also look at the wear pattern on your shoes. People who overpronate tend to wear out the inside of the heel and the inside of the ball of the foot faster than any other part of the shoe. People who underpronate tend to wear out the outer edge of their heels first.

Prioritizing Injury Prevention

Nothing puts the brakes on a running routine like pain, discomfort and injury. Problems like plantar fasciitis, Achilles tendonitis, IT band syndrome and more are often thought of as runner’s injuries because they are so common with this demographic. 

Avoiding injury is about knowing your limits and exercising responsibly: think stretching beforehand and gently ramping up to a new workout routine rather than immediately diving into high-intensity regimens. And, it’s also about wearing the right gear. These painful injuries can leave you asking, what is a good stability and cushioning shoe? 

Finding a shoe that supports a natural gait can make running easier and more enjoyable by reducing stress and strain on your body. This means less pain right after your run, and less risk of injury over the long-term as you pursue your goals. 

If you’ve been on a journey that began with asking, “what is a stability shoe?” we hope you’ve learned more about overpronation and the benefits of a neutral gait. Shoes with an ergonomic design, ample arch support and patented KURUSOLE technology like the KURU ATOM for men and women may help you walk more naturally, so you can experience less pain and more life.

Sourcing

• What’s the Difference between Stability and Motion Control Running Shoes?
• Overpronation – Cleveland Clinic
• What Are Neutral Running Shoes?
• Best Running Shoes for Flat Feet in 2022 with Stability and Motion Control
• DOCTORS OF RUNNING STABILITY RUNNING SHOE RESOURCE PAGE

About Us

For all media inquiries, please contact us at pr@kurufootwear.com.